Wine is a unique beverage in many ways. It undergoes a complex production process, comes in numerous styles, and offers a wide variety of flavors. And it comes in cork-sealed bottles. Why is this the case in a world of plastic packages? Why Are Corks Used for Wine Bottles?
Corks are used for wine bottles because they create a tight seal. At the same time, they allow a little bit of oxygen to get into the bottle so that the wine can breathe. This oxidation process leads to more delicate flavors, smoother tannins, and a more balanced drinking experience.
In this article, we will discuss the history, production, and purpose of corks in detail. And we will learn about the advantages and disadvantages of corks over other types of bottle closures.
The History of Corks
Bottle stoppers from cork have been around for thousands of years. Even before the invention of glass bottles, some winemakers sealed their containers with cork. Archeologists found remains of cork stoppers in old Egyptian tombs, but also in ancient Greece. Nevertheless, it was a rather unusual way to seal containers.
In medieval, it became a common practice to make both bottles and bottle stoppers from glass. While this combination was a safe way to keep the liquids inside the container, it was hard to open it. It was quite normal that an attempt to remove the glass seal resulted in a broken bottleneck. Alternative solutions like oil-soaked rags also had their downsides.
In the 17th century, winemakers found a better solution. As glassblowing became a more refined art, artisans could create standardized bottle designs with more narrow necks. And with cork stoppers, it was possible to seal these bottles safely and open them easily. One of the first persons to use cork stoppers was Dom Perignon. The Benedictine monk, who is famous for inventing Champagne, used cork together with wire to seal bottles of sparkling wine.
What Are Corks Made Of?
Cork is a natural material that comes from the bark of oak trees. More specifically, it’s made from the bark of Quercus suber, an evergreen tree that is native to Spain, Portugal, and some parts of North Africa.
This bark has a unique honeycomb-like cell structure that contains around 90% air. This structure makes it light and elastic. Nevertheless, it’s non-permeable and qualifies as an excellent material for bottle sealing.
How Are Cork Stoppers Made?
It takes between 15 and 25 years until Quercus suber trees are ready for harvest. Workers peel the bark from their trunks with axes or machetes without cutting them down. It’s important to mention that the trees don’t take permanent damage from this procedure. They regrow their bark and are ready for another harvest in 7 to 10 years. With each growth cycle, the cork gets better in quality. In fact, trees that are about 100 years old produce the best cork.
After the harvest, the workers boil the bark to remove impurities and sterilize it. Next, they dry the material until it has the optimal texture and cut it into the typical cylindrical shape. Usually, high-quality stoppers are the result of manual labor, while machines cut out lower quality corks.
What Are the Benefits of Cork Stoppers?
As indicated earlier in this article, cork stoppers provide some important benefits for winemakers. But they also have other gains. Let’s find out about them.
Most types of wine benefit from breathing. When they are exposed to oxygen, they develop more complex aromas, and their tannins get less dominant. In some cases, aeration also can help get rid of unpleasant flavors. As a result, the wine becomes more balanced and more enjoyable. But too much oxygen can harm wine and cause it to spoil. So the right dose of oxygen is vital to improve a wine.
With its porous structure, natural cork provides the right conditions for optimal airflow. It lets about one milligram of oxygen per year into the bottle. With this small amount, wine can rise to its full potential without going off.
With changing temperatures, liquids like wines expand and contract. This can become a problem, especially when it happens repeatedly. A wine that regularly expands and contracts can damage a solid stopper or push it out of the bottle ultimately.
The elastic structure of cork allows it to adapt to the wine’s expansion and contraction to some extent. Thus, it reduces the risk of a leak significantly. It can’t lower it to zero, though.
Cork is a natural product from a renewable resource. Its production doesn’t harm the environment.
Also, corks are 100% recyclable. Like other plant matter, you can simply compost them. They need a couple of years to compose, but they will without any remainings. Alternatively, you can use them to craft wine-related decor for your home.
What Are the Downsides of Cork Stoppers?
Although natural corks are highly beneficial for wine and great for the environment, they have some faults.
No Cork Is Like the Other
We’ve already discussed that the quality of corks depends on the age of the trees. But there are a couple of other factors that contribute to their quality and, in particular, their porousness.
With the different levels of quality and porousness, winemakers face the challenge of finding the right corks for their wines. The process of finding those that match a specific type of wine best can be long and hard. And it always includes the risk of choosing the wrong one and harming the wine.
Cork Can Promote Taint
You might have experienced wine that smells moldy, like a wet newspaper or a damp cardboard box. This smell is the outcome of taint or TCA. TCA is the abbreviation for 2,4,6-trichloroanisole. This strong chemical forms when plant phenols, chlorine, and mold interact with each other.
TCA can be present in the bark of cork oak trees even before the harvest. But it’s also possible that it originates from barrels, storage boxes, or other wooden materials.
If a cork stopper that contains TCA gets in contact with the wine, it will impart its aggressive smell on it over time. This wine won’t be a health risk for consumers, but it won’t be enjoyable anymore either. The only thing you can do with this “corked” wine is to pour it away.
Cork Is Fragile
Due to its porous structure, cork is fragile. When it dries out, cork pieces can break off a cork stopper and fall into the wine. The same can happen when you try to open the bottle with a metal tool. Drinking wine with cork particles in it isn’t a great experience, and neither is fishing them out of your glass.
For this reason, you should store wine bottles with a cork seal lying on their side. In this position, the wine stays in contact with the stopper. It keeps the cork moist and prevents it from drying out.
Natural Cork Is Expensive
With all the manual labor involved in producing them, natural cork stoppers are cost-intensive. And with prices between 0.50 and 1 USD, they can be up to three times as expensive as bottle stoppers from other materials. Winemakers have to factor in these extra costs. Therefore, vintners that produce high-end wines are more likely to use natural cork than those who make affordable wines.
Alternatives to Natural Corks
Besides natural cork, winemakers use a couple of other materials to seal their bottles. These alternatives include reconstructed cork, synthetic cork, and screw caps. In comparison to natural cork, they have individual advantages and disadvantages.
Reconstructed cork is basically recycled natural cork. This material is made by gluing together the remaining pieces of the production of high-quality cork stoppers. It’s also possible to use grounded old corks for this purpose.
Because it’s made of natural cork, reconstructed cork has a similar structure and comparable characteristics as natural cork: It allows the wine to breathe and is a reliable seal. It’s significantly cheaper to produce, though. Thus, producers of low-cost wines tend to prefer it over the expensive natural alternative.
Unfortunately, reconstructed corks have similar disadvantages as natural cork: They can contain TCA and cork a wine, and they also can break apart. Because of the glue they contain, these risks are rather low, though.
Of course, there is a synthetic alternative to natural cork stoppers. These plastic seals are made from polyethylene, just like milk bottles or garbage bins. They offer several advantages over natural or reconstructed cork:
- Depending on the manufacturer’s preferences, they have a consistent and reliable structure optimized for a specific level of aeration. So winemakers don’t need to go through the try-and-error process to find the right bottle stoppers.
- They are immune against TCA, so the risk of corking wine is almost zero.
- Synthetic corks are more affordable because producing them is a less time- and cost-intensive process than making natural cork.
- For the environment, synthetic corks are significantly worse, because they don’t decompose over time. Despite this disadvantage, especially producers of low-quality wines tend to prefer synthetic corks.
Screw Cap Closures
Screw caps for wine bottles emerged around the late 1950s. But it was not until the 2000s when commercial winemakers began using them in place of traditional corks. This switch to screw caps began in New Zealand and Australia but expanded worldwide. Nowadays, wines with screw caps often are considered low-quality wines. But actually, many high-end wineries utilize them as well due to the benefits they offer:
- One of these benefits is their ease of use. It’s much easier to open a bottle with a screw cap than one with a cork. No tools like bottle openers are necessary, and it’s almost impossible to break screw caps.
- As they don’t contain plant matter, screw caps aren’t prone to TCA. Thus, they minimize the risk of accidentally corking wine for winemakers.
- Screw caps are made from aluminum, so they’re air-proof. For young, crisp wines that don’t need much aeration, this is a crucial feature, because it prevents overoxidation.
On the other hand, it means that bold wines can’t benefit from exposure to a bit of oxygen. So the typical aging process that improves flavors and softens tannins won’t take place.
Finally, screw caps are not very eco-friendly because they aren’t compostable. They are recyclable but only through energy-intensive procedures.
Are Wines With Corks Better Than Wines With Screw Caps?
Screw caps aren’t fundamentally better or worse than cork stoppers. Winemakers have to decide which type of bottle closure they use based on the wine they want to seal:
- Screw caps are the right choice for light wines that are meant to be drunk when young. To conserve their freshness, air-proof bottle seals are necessary. Most white and rosé wines belong to this category.
- Cork stoppers are the proper solution for complex, full-bodied wines. As these wines benefit from exposure to oxygen, cork is the right material for them. Thus, many red wines, as well as some oaked whites, come in cork-sealed bottles.
How to Open a Wine Bottle Without Breaking the Cork
As mentioned above, fragility is one main issue of cork stoppers. They’re likely to crumble when consumers try to open the bottle.
But it’s possible to minimize the risk of breaking a cork by following some simple rules:
- Store Your Wine Properly. As mentioned before, you should store cork-sealed wine on their side. This position ensures that the wine stays in contact with the cork and prevents it from getting dry and porous, so it doesn’t break as easily.
- Use the Right Corkscrew. Depending on the age (and value) of the wine, you should use a different corkscrew. A basic model is the right choice for the majority of wines. Only for old vintages or very expensive bottles, you should consider using a two-pronged bottle opener. It’s a little harder to handle these openers, but they minimize the risk of breaking the cork.
Two-Pronged Bottle Opener
- Use the Corkscrew Properly. When using a standard corkscrew, make sure to place it in the center of the cork. Deviating for just half a centimeter increases the risk of breaking the cork. Twist the corkscrew into the cork slowly. Stop when about one twist is left, so the corkscrew doesn’t go all the way through the cork. Pull it out carefully without shaking the bottle and the corkscrew too much.
How to Deal With a Broken Cork
Even with proper case, pieces break off the cork and fall into the wine sometimes. But if you realize it and take action immediately, this won’t be a big problem.
Pour the wine through a proper filter into a decanter. As a filter, you can use a coffee filter from paper or a piece of cheesecloth. If the cork pieces in the wine aren’t too big, a fine cullender might be an option as well.
Having the right decanter for your wine is key. If it exposes the wine to too much oxygen, it might cause overoxidation.
In case you don’t own a decanter, you can pour the wine directly into glasses. Because the glasses have a wider opening than a decanter, this might be a bit tricky, though. You have to pour very slowly and make sure that the filter doesn’t get out of place. It might be a job for two people.
For many people, wine corks are a fancy tradition that makes wine stand out from less fancy beverages. For others, they are an annoying obstacle on their way to a good glass of wine. With the knowledge from this article, you know better than all of them. Cork stoppers actually serve a meaningful purpose for wine by contributing to their taste and smell. Next, try to experience the differences yourself. Can you sense the differences between wine with a screw cap and a cork-sealed wine?